Bumble Bee Recovery
The yellow-banded bumble bee (Bombus terricola), the rusty-patched bumble bee (Bombus affinis), and the western bumble bee (Bombus occidentalis) were all once some of the most common bumble bee species within their ranges in Canada. All three species are closely related – they belong to the same subgenus Bombus sensu stricto. Unfortunately, their numbers have all been declining rapidly since the mid-1990s. All three species have been assessed by the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada (COSEWIC) to be in decline. In 2010, the rusty-patched bumble bee was assessed as Endangered in 2014, the western bumble bee subspecies occidentalis was assessed as Threatened – and in 2015, the yellow-banded bumble bee was assessed as of Special Concern.
Since the launch of the Native Pollinator Initiative’s Bumble Bee Recovery program in 2013, we have collaborated with numerous partners internationally to develop and maintain a variety of native pollinator conservation projects, including: a conservation breeding program for the yellow-banded bumble bee, biodiversity monitoring, the Bumble Bee Watch community science database and targeted community science training programs utilizing it, public educational workshops, and piloting the use of artificial colony nest boxes as a conservation tool. Though many of our bumble bee recovery programs are based in Ontario, since 2016 we have been building relationships and expanding programs into Alberta as well, with goals of working with the western bumble bee in the future once we have developed reliable techniques for bumble bee conservation interventions.
We are currently developing techniques to establish conservation breeding colonies of at-risk native bumble bee species. Through rearing these bumble bees in captivity, we have the rare opportunity to observe all aspects of the colony life cycle up close and personal, allowing us to collect crucial data on the biology of the species so that we can develop a better understanding of potential reasons for their decline. Our ultimate goal is to safely reintroduce these bees into now-vacant areas of their historic range.
Originally, we focused our attention on the rusty-patched bumble bee. However, despite intensive annual searches throughout Ontario since 2012, our team has been unable to locate a single individual of this species. The last sighting occurred in 2009 at Pinery Provincial Park in southwestern Ontario. That’s why we turned our attention to the closely related yellow-banded bumble bee. Using this species as a surrogate, we are developing conservation breeding techniques that we can apply to the rusty-patched bumble bee if and when queens become available.
Conservation breeding efforts began in Ontario in 2014. Each spring, our team scours the province for yellow-banded queens that we use to try to establish breeding colonies. In order to establish managed colonies, wild queens must be collected as early as possible in the spring, before they have begun a colony in the wild. The queens are then provided with a nesting space in ideal conditions and fed regularly. If all goes well, they will first produce workers, then males, and then, finally, new queens. The males and new queens leave the colony to mate, and all but the new queens die off naturally: new fertilized queens will search for a place outside the colony to hibernate for the winter. These queens will then hopefully emerge to start colonies of their own in the spring.
Once we establish a self-sustaining population of disease-free colonies, we can begin developing strategies to release mated queens into suitable habitat to boost wild populations. Meanwhile, research with captive colonies has and continues to provide insights into threats facing wild populations, including impacts of pesticides, parasite levels, and changes in genetic variation.
To improve our understanding of bumble bee populations in Ontario, our staff conduct surveys of bumble bees all throughout the province – ranging from our southernmost sites in Norfolk County all the way up north to areas surrounding Thunder Bay.
We target historic and current locations of at-risk bumble bees to track the health of local populations over time, but we also look to expand our survey coverage every year in the hopes of locating new populations of these rare bumble bees. Though our target species include the yellow-banded and rusty-patched bumble bees in Ontario, we also work to monitor populations of other species that appear to be in decline, including the gypsy cuckoo bumble bee (Bombus bohemicus), the American bumble bee (Bombus pensylvanicus), and the yellow bumble bee (Bombus fervidus).
From our surveys, conducted since 2013, we have observed that yellow-banded bumble bee populations appear to be more abundant further north in the province. Beginning in 2018, during intensive spring surveys both to collect yellow-banded bumble bee queens for conservation breeding and to monitor bumble bee biodiversity, we manage additional regional field crews to increase our survey coverage in these critical areas. Our main field crew works out of Guelph, and we have now added a spring crew based in Sudbury, and one based in Thunder Bay. With the help of additional staff, we hope to continue to collect baseline information on both populations that appear to be thriving (those north of Lake Superior) and populations that may be declining (certain southern populations) so that we can assess within which areas the yellow-banded bumble bee may become more critically threatened, in real time.
In 2014, we launched BumbleBeeWatch.org in collaboration with several partners. This website allows community scientists to help us locate populations of declining species, assess changes in population size and distribution, and track invasive species throughout North America – crucial information that will help shape our hands-on recovery work.
Starting in 2015, we have also developed and implemented an ever-expanding Bumble Bee Watch community science hands-on survey training program. This survey program engages the community in bumble bee conservation by teaching them the same survey techniques that professional researchers use, and provides them with the equipment and know-how to independently monitor native bumble bees within our targeted locations throughout the summer months. The first program WPC developed takes place every year at Pinery Provincial Park near Grand Bend, Ontario, selected as it is the last known location of the rusty-patched bumble bee. Since then, we have expanded to host programs at multiple other locations in Ontario with known observations of species at risk, as well as a program at Glenbow Ranch Provincial Park near Calgary, Alberta: a known location of the western bumble bee. Thanks to the dedicated efforts of our trained community scientists, we have been able to record multiple additional observations of rare and at-risk species at these sites.
In 2019, we expanded our BumbleBeeWatch.org volunteer community science program by engaging additional volunteers through our Train-the-Trainer program, which was first implemented in 2018. This program provides a one-day course and support throughout the bumble bee season for organizations and landowners who are interested in running their own volunteer-based programs using Bumble Bee Watch. Through this multi-leveled instruction program, we hope to expand search efforts across the country, growing our organizational capacity for training citizen scientists to locate and identify native bumble bees. If you are interested in launching a volunteer survey project in your area, please contact us.
In 2020, our community science and educational programs were put on hold in accordance with pandemic safety restrictions. WPC staff, along with a few dedicated volunteers, submitted 440 species-specific bumble bee records to Bumble Bee Watch collected through weekly surveys at Pinery Provincial Park. By attending virtual conferences and delivering educational content online, we maintained an active position in the pollinator community in Canada and abroad.
The use of bumble bee colony nest boxes (sometimes referred to as artificial domiciles) to obtain or relocate colonies of bumble bees for research and crop pollination has been a common technique used by academics, mainly in western Canada and New Zealand. However, their potential use in conservation and for monitoring at-risk species is highly understudied. Since bumble bee nests are usually quite cryptic – most of us haven’t even encountered one unless they decided to nest in one of your abandoned bird boxes or under your deck! – using artificial boxes to study bumble bee colony growth and development in the field is a great alternative to trying to search for natural nesting sites. With minimal work done to-date on occupancy success for colony boxes in Ontario, and a lack of evaluation of their ability to help with data collection on bumble bee biology and distributions across Canada, we saw an opening!
Starting in 2017, we began a pilot project investigating the use of artificial nest boxes for conservation in locations specifically selected for historic observations of our target at-risk bumble bee species. Through a project led by a graduate student at the University of Guelph, we are analyzing results from 400 nest boxes that were installed at multiple sites across Ontario.
Thousands of bumble bee sightings are reported on Bumble Bee Watch each year, from Puerto Rico to Baffin Island, with steadily increasing engagement over time – since 2014, over 75,000 submissions have been recorded, with verified records of almost all of the North American fauna. Bumble bees have been submitted from every state, province, and territory, and the data collected have been used to help with government species assessments across the continent. Over 800 rusty-patched bumble bees have been spotted throughout the midwestern U.S., and observations of nearly 800 yellow-banded bumble bees and nearly 900 western bumble bees have been submitted from locations throughout their range in Canada and the United States.
Meanwhile, conservation breeding of yellow-banded bumble bees has proven to be challenging. We had limited success in 2014 and 2015, but through constant refinement of our techniques we hit a major milestone in 2016, with our colonies producing their first new queens. In 2017, we experienced a major setback when what appears to be a pathogen outbreak took a huge toll on our lab population – we experienced higher than normal mortality in queens both before and after they had started colonies. However, despite these difficulties, we still managed to produce over quadruple the number of new queens of the previous year. We continued testing new methods in 2018 and 2019, and have experienced some success with productivity, but major success in preventing the spread of pathogens and parasites. In 2020, our program was put on hold to comply with province-wide safety restrictions. In 2021, we will continue to refine and improve our husbandry techniques to achieve the highest success possible, including collaborating with new partners across North America. Full results over six years of working with managed colonies are shown below.
|Colonies producing eggs||2||17||37||15||11||6||n/a|
|Colonies with workers||0||7||21||7||8||0||n/a|
|Colonies with males||0||1||18||5||0||0||n/a|
Once our conservation breeding techniques are yielding satisfactory results, we will begin developing release methods to effectively boost wild yellow-banded bumble bee populations. We may also be able to use these techniques to return the rusty-patched bumble bee to its historic range in Ontario and Quebec, most likely by using queens captured from the United States.
Another option for using conservation breeding to help species recover is with populations of the western bumble bee. However, disease concerns for working with this species are paramount – one possible cause of their sharp decline may be issues with high pathogen levels, potentially exacerbated by their former use in commercial breeding operations for greenhouse pollination. Raising the western bumble bee for greenhouse pollination has since been discontinued due to massive colony losses attributed to high pathogen loads. Thus, we may pursue alternative methods for intervening to help save the western bumble bee – including investigating the use of colony nest boxes for translocations of individuals from areas of higher density to areas within their range from which they have been lost.
Smith, T.A., J.P. Strange, E.C. Evans, B.M. Sadd, J.C. Steiner, J.M. Mola and K. Traylor-Holzer. (Eds.). 2020. Rusty Patched Bumble Bee, Bombus affinis, Ex Situ Assessment and Planning Workshop: Final Report. IUCN SSC Conservation Planning Specialist Group, Apple Valley, MN, USA.
Johnson, S., Tompkins, M., Tompkins, H., & Colla, S. (2019). Artificial Domicile Use by Bumble Bees (Bombus; Hymenoptera: Apidae) in Ontario, Canada. Journal of Insect Science. 19(7): 1-5.
MacPhail, V.J., Richardson, L.L. & Colla, S.R. 2019. Incorporating citizen science, museum specimens, and field work into the assessment of extinction risk of the American Bumble bee (Bombus pensylvanicus De Geer 1773) in Canada. J. Insect Conserv. 23: 597.
MacPhail, V.J, Ferguson, S., Tompkins, H., Colla, S.R. 2018. The missing link: A case for increased consideration for plant-pollinator interactions for species at-risk recovery in Ontario. Journal for Nature Conservation. 42 (2018):1-6
Liczner AR, MacPhail VJ, Woollett DA, Richards NL, Colla SR (2021) Training and usage of detection dogs to better understand bumble bee nesting habitat: Challenges and opportunities. PLoS ONE 16(5): e0249248. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0249248
Sarah joined the Native Pollinator Initiative as Lead Biologist in February 2021, where she manages the native pollinator recovery programs across Canada. Sarah first became interested in studying pollinator conservation during her BSc in environmental sciences at the University of Guelph. She took multiple courses on pollinators and conducted her own research on bumble bees and pesticides. These experiences sparked her interest in conserving bees throughout Canada.
Sarah completed her MSc at York University, which was focused on gaining a better understanding of the floral resource requirements of honey bee hives and identifying whether urban beehives are negatively impacting wild bee communities, including bumble bees. Within her BSc and MSc she has gained many skills that make her qualified for leading bumble bee recovery, including population monitoring experience, husbandry skills and knowledge, and identification skills. Before finding her passion for bees she also worked at Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, and Ontario Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks researching soil physics, food safety, and water quality, respectively.
Conservation Outreach and Field Biologist
Tiffani was WPC’s Bumble Bee Conservation Technician in 2017 and fell in love with the work. Since then, she has led two survey field seasons for the program in Thunder Bay, an integral component to the yellow-banded captive breeding program. She also led monitoring surveys, research projects, community outreach, and managed a community science program for the program in Alberta. Currently, her role entails leading field work and community outreach elements for the Bumble Bee Recovery Program, as well as assisting in the breeding lab. She is currently finishing her Master’s in conservation and biodiversity at the University of Toronto, focusing her studies on pollinators.
WPC hosts Dr. Laurence Packer to discuss bee diversity. Dr. Packer is a professor at York University and a world expert on wild bees. He also manages a world class bee collection – with over 500,000 bee specimens from all over the world.
WPC participated in a conservation planning workshop for the rusty patched bumble bee, one of North America’s most threatened pollinators and one of WPC’s focal species. The workshop brought together a wide range of global bee conservation experts to evaluate and recommend conservation breeding and other ex situ strategies to complement existing recovery strategies in the wild for this endangered species. The report highlights the critical importance of WPC’s leading efforts to develop conservation breeding techniques for threatened bumble bees.
Check out this stunning story map by WPC”s BumbleBeeWatch partners The Xerces Society.
- The Rogers Foundation
- The Schad Foundation
- Alberta Ecotrust
- Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry- Species at Risk Stewardship Fund and Species at Risk Research Fund
- Bonterra Organic Wines
- Burt’s Bees