Evolutionary Distinctiveness: A conservation tool for protecting Canada’s most unique species

When we talk about conserving species, we often think of those most at risk—species on the brink of extinction. But what if there was a way to prioritize species based not only on how endangered they are but also on how unique they are?

Canada is home to some truly unique animals that come in all sorts of shapes and sizes. However, this can make things difficult when tasked with the mission of identifying the most unique animals in the country. This is the task that researchers at Wildlife Preservation Canada and Simon Fraser University set out to accomplish, using an evolutionary perspective to compare different species. Using this information, Wildlife Preservation Canada can help determine which species to start working to save.

What is evolutionary distinctiveness?

Evolutionary distinctiveness describes the uniqueness of a species’ evolutionary history on the Tree of Life compared to other species. The researchers at Simon Fraser university have been involved in calculating evolutionary distinctiveness scores at a global scale in partnership with the Zoological Society of London’s Edge of Existence program (www.edgeofexistence.org). For this new national project, the researchers looked at several groups of animals in Canada: mammals, birds, turtles, snakes and lizards, and amphibians. They then compared the species in these groups and mapped out their family trees to see how they related to all the other species in Canada. Species with higher ED values are those that have fewer close relatives in Canada and more unique evolutionary history in millions of years.

Canada’s most evolutionarily distinct animals

So, which Canadian species were the most distinct? You might want to answer with one of Canada’s iconic species like the national animal – the beaver – or perhaps the moose, or the polar bear. But, as a matter of fact, the most evolutionarily distinct Canadian animal was the spiny softshell turtle!

The spiny softshell turtle is certainly a peculiar-looking species with its flexible, leathery shell and long, snorkel-like snout. These turtles can be found in Ontario and Quebec, and are one of the largest freshwater turtle species in North America. But unfortunately, they have been listed as one of Canada’s rarest species for over 20 years. Conservation groups have worked hard to protect and recover these endangered turtles, but it has been challenging with all the threats they face, including habitat destruction and poaching. . Now, we know that if we let them disappear from Canada, we would lose almost 180 million years of unique evolutionary history. This shows how important it is to prioritize the conservation of this species and its unique legacy amongst Canadian wildlife.

In addition to the spiny softshell turtle, other reptiles and amphibians had high ED scores compared to the other groups of animals. Among the amphibians, the top-scorer was the common mudpuppy which is the largest salamander in Canada. These salamanders can grow over 40 cm long, and they spend their entire lives in the water which is why they retain gills for breathing. Unfortunately, like the spiny softshell turtle, the mudpuppy has recently been assessed as a species at risk of extinction due to their declining numbers. With their almost 160 million years of unique evolutionary history, this is another species that needs our help to avoid disappearing from the Canadian wild.

The most evolutionary distinct Canadian amphibian, the common mudpuppy. Photo: Matt Keevil

In fact, species at risk of extinction tended to have higher ED scores than species that are not currently at risk of extinction. This indicates that us conservationists will need to act quickly in order to preserve all of this unique evolutionary history.

Among the other groups that the researchers explored, the Virginia opossum was the top mammal, which is fitting considering the fact that it is the only marsupial in the country. Meanwhile, the belted kingfisher took the lead amongst the birds, and the northern alligator lizard ranked the highest among snakes and lizards.

Left: A Virginia opossum (Photo: Cody Pope); Middle: A belted kingfisher (Photo: Derek Zandvliet); Right: A northern alligator lizard (Photo: Patrick Moldowan).

Why is this research important?

Many species around the world are facing declines due to human impacts and conservation funding is difficult to acquire. This means that conservationists have to make the difficult decision of prioritizing which species to focus our efforts on first. There are many different ways to assess and prioritize species, from their population counts to the significance of their ecological roles, but these can be challenging to measure effectively. ED offers us some new perspectives on the long unique evolutionary paths that have brought species to where they are today, and the evolutionary legacy that these species carry.

This research highlights the critical place reptiles and amphibians hold in Canada’s biodiversity. This ED metric helps to build the case for species that might otherwise be overlooked, and this helps with WPC’s mission to save the rarest species in Canada.

This research is an important first step in exploring the applications of ED. ED scores have been calculated at the global scale, but work to save rare species tends to happen more often at national scales, and this is the first time ED scores have been scored at a national scale anywhere in the world. Next steps could include calculating these scores for other countries and groups of species, like plants and butterflies.

If you would like to read more about this research on evolutionary distinctiveness, find the research article here: Kominek, E., Cornies, O., McCurdy-Adams, H., and A.O. Mooers. 2023 [2024]. Evolutionary isolation of Canadian terrestrial vertebrate species. The Canadian Field-Naturalist 137:367-380. https://www.canadianfieldnaturalist.ca/index.php/cfn/article/view/2673

Rachel Fallas

Reptile and Amphibian Program Biologist

Rachel joined WPC’s Reptile & Amphibian program in 2024 to help coordinate research and conservation activities in southern Ontario. She has been involved in herpetological research throughout her undergraduate and master’s degree and is currently completing her M.Sc. on the topic of massasauga rattlesnake overwintering habitat. Rachel is passionate about wildlife conservation and her interests lie in the spatial and thermal ecology of herpetofauna and the ecohydrology of their habitat.

Hannah McCurdy-Adams

Reptile and Amphibian Program Development Coordinator

Hannah is developing the national reptile and amphibian initiative for Wildlife Preservation Canada. She has worked with experts in the fields of road ecology, physiology, and genetics. Hannah has been involved in conservation projects for at-risk reptiles and amphibians in Canada for a decade.

We need your help

Donate to save endangered species